As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our site at no extra cost to you.
The right dog carrier depends on how you travel. For airline travel, the Sherpa Original Deluxe ($68) is the most trusted airline-approved option. For hands-free adventures, the PetAmi Backpack Carrier ($39) keeps your dog close while you hike or bike. For car trips and vet visits, the MidWest Spree ($26) is the most affordable hard-sided option that gets the job done.
Choosing a dog carrier sounds simple until you realize there are hundreds of options in completely different styles — soft-sided, hard-sided, backpacks, slings, wheeled, airline-approved. The wrong choice means a stressed dog, a rejected carrier at the airport gate, or wasted money on something your pet refuses to enter. This guide breaks down exactly what to look for based on your travel style, then recommends the best carrier in each category.
Types of Dog Carriers (Which One Do You Need?)
Soft-Sided Carriers
Best for airline travel and everyday use. They are lightweight, flexible, and fit under most airplane seats. Most dogs prefer soft carriers because they feel more den-like. Look for airline-approved dimensions (typically 18 x 11 x 11 inches or smaller) and mesh ventilation panels on at least 3 sides.
Hard-Sided Carriers
Best for car travel and vet visits. They are sturdier, easier to clean, and provide more protection during car rides. The trade-off is they are bulkier and heavier. Some dogs feel more secure in hard carriers because the walls do not flex.
Backpack Carriers
Best for hiking, biking, and hands-free activities. Your dog rides on your back while you keep both hands free. Look for ventilation, a sturdy frame, and weight limits that match your dog. Most backpack carriers work for dogs up to 15 to 20 pounds.
Premium/Crash-Tested Carriers
Best for safety-conscious pet parents. These carriers are tested to withstand car crash forces, giving your dog real protection during accidents. They cost more but provide peace of mind that regular carriers cannot match.
What to Look For in a Dog Carrier
Size: Your dog should be able to stand, turn around, and lie down comfortably. Measure your dog from nose to tail base and from floor to top of head while standing. Add 2 to 3 inches to each measurement for the minimum carrier size.
Ventilation: Mesh panels on at least 3 sides are essential, especially for airline travel. Poor ventilation leads to overheating and anxiety.
Weight limit: Always check the manufacturer’s weight limit, not just the carrier dimensions. A carrier that fits your dog’s body may not support their weight properly.
Entry points: Top-loading carriers are easier for nervous dogs — you can lower them in gently. Side-loading is more natural for confident dogs who walk in on their own. The best carriers have both.
Airline compliance: If you fly, check your specific airline’s pet carrier dimensions BEFORE buying. Requirements vary by airline and even by aircraft type.
Our Top 4 Picks
1. Sherpa Original Deluxe — Best for Airline Travel
Price: $68.22 · Check Price on Amazon
The Sherpa Original Deluxe is the gold standard for airline travel. It comes with a Guaranteed On Board program — if your pet is denied boarding with this carrier, Sherpa covers the cost of your ticket. The spring wire frame lets you squeeze it under tighter seats, and the top and side entry points make loading easy.
Best for: Frequent flyers and anyone who needs a guaranteed airline-approved carrier.
Pros:
- Guaranteed On Board program with major airlines
- Spring wire frame compresses to fit under seats
- Top and side entry points
- Machine-washable faux lambskin liner
- Mesh panels on all sides for ventilation
Cons:
- Not the cheapest option at $68
- Faux lambskin liner can get warm in summer
2. PetAmi Deluxe Backpack Carrier — Best for Hands-Free Adventures
Price: $39 · Check Price on Amazon
The PetAmi Backpack Carrier lets you take your dog on hikes, bike rides, and walks while keeping both hands free. It features ventilated mesh windows, a built-in safety buckle to keep your dog secure, and padded shoulder straps for comfort on longer trips. The collapsible bowl included is a nice bonus for on-the-go hydration.
Best for: Active pet parents who want their small dog with them on outdoor adventures.
Pros:
- Hands-free design with padded shoulder straps
- Ventilated mesh on 3 sides
- Built-in safety buckle and collar attachment
- Airline-approved dimensions
- Collapsible water bowl included
Cons:
- Max 18 lbs — not for medium or large dogs
- Can get warm on hot days despite ventilation
3. MidWest Spree Travel Carrier — Best Budget Option
Price: $25.99 · Check Price on Amazon
If you need a simple, reliable carrier for vet visits and car trips without spending a fortune, the MidWest Spree delivers. The hard-sided design is easy to clean (just wipe it down), the ventilated sides keep air flowing, and the carrying handle makes it comfortable to transport. It assembles in seconds with no tools needed.
Best for: Vet visits, car trips, and anyone who wants a no-nonsense carrier under $30.
Pros:
- Under $26 — best value on this list
- Hard-sided plastic is easy to clean
- Ventilated design with wire door
- No-tool assembly
- Comfortable carrying handle
Cons:
- Not airline-approved for in-cabin travel
- Heavier than soft-sided options
- No top-loading option
4. Sleepypod Air — Best Premium Crash-Tested Carrier
Price: $199.99 · Check Price on Amazon
The Sleepypod Air is for pet parents who want the safest carrier money can buy. It is one of the few carriers that is both crash-tested by the Center for Pet Safety AND airline-approved. The PPRS Handilock system secures it to your car seatbelt, giving your dog real crash protection — not just a marketing claim.
Best for: Safety-focused pet parents who travel frequently by car and plane.
Pros:
- Crash-tested by Center for Pet Safety
- Airline-approved for in-cabin travel
- PPRS Handilock seatbelt attachment
- Ultra-lightweight at 3.5 lbs
- Premium build quality
Cons:
- $200 is a significant investment
- Limited color options
- Smaller interior than some competitors at the same listed size
Quick Comparison Table
| Carrier | Best For | Price | Type | Max Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sherpa Original Deluxe | Airline travel | $68.22 | Soft-sided | 16 lbs |
| PetAmi Backpack | Hiking/hands-free | $39 | Backpack | 18 lbs |
| MidWest Spree | Budget/vet visits | $25.99 | Hard-sided | 16 lbs |
| Sleepypod Air | Safety/crash-tested | $199.99 | Soft-sided | 15 lbs |
Frequently Asked Questions
What size carrier does my dog need?
Measure your dog from nose to tail base and from floor to top of head while standing. Add 2 to 3 inches to each measurement. Your dog should be able to stand up, turn around, and lie down comfortably inside the carrier.
Are soft or hard carriers better for dogs?
Soft carriers are better for airline travel and everyday use because they are lightweight and flexible. Hard carriers are better for car trips and vet visits because they are sturdier and easier to clean. Most dog owners benefit from having one of each.
How do I get my dog used to a carrier?
Start by leaving the carrier open at home with a treat or blanket inside. Let your dog explore it on their own terms for a few days. Then practice short trips (5 to 10 minutes) before longer travel. Never force your dog into a carrier — it creates negative associations.
Can I use a dog carrier as a crate?
A carrier works as a temporary crate for short periods, but it should not replace a proper crate for daily use. Carriers are designed for travel and are generally smaller than recommended crate sizes for home use.
Which airlines allow dogs in the cabin?
Most major US airlines including Delta, United, American, Southwest, and JetBlue allow small dogs in-cabin in an approved carrier. Each airline has specific size requirements and fees (typically $95 to $150 each way). Always check your airline’s current pet policy before booking.
Final Verdict
For most dog owners, the Sherpa Original Deluxe ($68) is the best overall carrier — it is airline-approved, comfortable, and backed by a boarding guarantee. If you want a hands-free option for outdoor adventures, the PetAmi Backpack ($39) is excellent value. Budget shoppers will love the MidWest Spree at just $26. And if safety is your top priority, the Sleepypod Air ($200) is the only crash-tested and airline-approved carrier on this list.